Information on Kerala IPR Academy veiled
By Online Security Authority on Aug 13, 2009 in Thoughts on Security
In pursuit of establishing an Intellectual Poperty Academy in Kerala, we pursued the RTI endeavor with a fresh demand for inspectingthe File No. 20311/Nodal(1)/08/Law, which was stated to be under different levels of deliberations. It is an interesting story altogether.
My friend, Mr. Prasanth (Blogger of SECULAR CITIZEN) filed his RTI Request on 29/06/09 with the following contents.
“With reference to the Letter No. 10508/Nodal 1/09/Law dated 24.06.2009, I may please be permitted to exercise my right under Section 2(j) of RTI Act to inspect the File No. 20311/Nodal(1)/08/Law for the purpose of taking notes, extracts or certified copies of relevant documents or records (including file notes), that are not exempted from disclosure under Section 8(1) of RTI Act. Please inform me a suitable date on which I can inspect the File.
You may kindly see the decision of State Information Commission in a similiar case
All the papers essentially identified and marked as “CABINET PAPERS” or any CABINET NOTE under Section 8(1)(i) may be withheld from inspection”.
He was expecting an early call from Law Department, inviting him to inspect the file. However PIO of Law Department vide letter No. 11478/Nodal I/09/Law dated 09.07.2009 denied the request stating that his demand for inspection of file could not be considered favorably since the information sought for is not accessible under Section 8(1)(i) of the Act. The Department once again cited the reason that the proposals are under different levels of deliberations. It is an oxymoron that the Government authorities treat RTI Request as a favour being sought. Further PIO failed to provide the reasons for applying Section 8(1)(i) on the ‘whole file content’.
But Mr. Prasanth was not in a mood to give up. He preferred an appeal to the Appellate Authority in Law Department, Govt. of Kerala on 13.07.09 under Section 19(1) of RTI Act, seeking a “speaking order”, either allowing him to access the information requested, or by providing the logic behind applying Section 8(1)(i) by PIO.
It took hardly a fortnight for him to realise that the bureaucracy was not lenient enough to abide by the principles of ‘Freedom of Information’. The reply from the Appellate Authority was very disappointing. Vide Letter No. 12462/Nodal I/09/Law dated 27/07/2009, the Appellate Authority turned down the scope of a “speaking order” positing that the decision of PIO did not suffer from any legal infirmity warranting a speaking order as requested.
It is the second instance at which the Law Department makes the deliberate attempt to conceal the information on the IPR Academy. Earlier, the Appellate Authority had just conceded to provide the information that the IPR Academy details are available at vide File No. 20311/Nodal(1)/08/Law, in an RTI process initiated to avail the following the information.
i) Aims/Mandates of the IPR Academy
ii) Reasons for proposing an IPR Academy (To know whether it is essential for Kerala)
iii) Proposed budget, proposed location and proposed area of the CAMPUS for the IPR Academy
iv) Constitutional details of the proposed IPR Academy including the functions of councils/committees (if any), faculty and Infrastructure.
v) The progress report and the latest status on setting up the IPR Academy.
Mr. Prasanth did not pursue the matter to the State Information Commission then. But he is very determined this time. A judicial process before the Commission is on the cards.
After all, why a “public authority” should “feel offended” when questions are asked to ensure the “accountability” to the “governed”? Is it that the“governed” (the masters in “Democracy”) have no right to question the “governing authority”? How will the “accountability” be ensured otherwise?
I’m of the opinion that this “attitude” of the “bureaucratic” set up would derail the “accountability” of the governmental system and the wisdom of parliamentarians in enacting the RTI Act. Success of RTI Act demands change in attitude of the public authorities.
R.S. Praveen Raj Article Source:http://www.articlesbase.com/intellectual-property-articles/information-on-kerala-ipr-academy-veiled-1124451.html
Scientist – IP Management & Technology Transfer
National Institute for Interdisciplinary Science & Technology (NIIST),
(Formerly RRL, Trivandrum), Industrial Estate P.O., Pappanamcode,
Thiruvananthapuram – 695 019.
Written by: OSAblogger / Bill Wardell - Please Read Our Latest OSA eZine Edition
Other Places You Can Find Me…
Digg - LinkedIn - OSA Community - Facebook - StumbleUpon - MyBlogLog
If you're a concerned parent, you may want to subscribe to the: OSA~RSS while your here, please JOIN our: OSA Forum... also Follow Me On Twitter Thanks for visiting!
OSA Related Posts -
Facing the Information Security Hole in 2009 Facing the Information Security Hole in 2009: The unacknowledged threat to our homeland and financial security Every few days there is yet another breach of information security. And each breach seems to be The Biggest Ever, until the next one is announced. It is now widely acknowledged by security...... -
Top Ten Signs You've Got a Trojan Image via Wikipedia I simply can't resist starting this with the obvious 'there's a giant wooden horse parked in your driveway'. Okay, now that I've got that out of my system, let's see what you might have on yours. There is nothing more frustrating than a computer that is either...... - Understanding Why You Should Want File Encryption Protection If you are on your computer daily, or even weekly, then you most likely have some essential information stored in files on it. Though you may lean toward thinking you are the only person able to read the information on the computer, unfortunately that may not be the case unless......
- Federal Computer Fraud and Abuse Act Remedies Potentially Available to Hawaii Employers for Deleted Files The federal Eastern District Court of Missouri recently issued a ruling that could broaden the remedies available to Hawaii employers for damage caused to computers by departing employees. Specifically, in Lasco Foods, Inc. v. Hall and Shaw Sales, Marketing, & Consulting, the Court interpreted the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act......
-
Wells Fargo customers will be able to import any electronic or digitized documents... Wells Fargo is promising its customers Security and convenience with its new vSafe service. The Web-based virtual safe-deposit box allows users to archive almost any file format, from Microsoft Word documents and PDFs, to audio and video files. Wells Fargo customers will be able to import any electronic or digitized......
OSA Related Websites -
The shame of Korea's orphan exportation I think it's important that we think about this and discuss it in some way, even those of us with Chinese children or soon-to-have Chinese children. It's not unusual for grown Korean adoptees (KADs) to think of themselves as exports...or at least to think of Korean adoption on the whole...... -
Will Prospective Law Students Listen to the Hard Truth? Too many unemployed (or under-employed) college graduates) choose graduate school as a default option. I have been consistent in this message, particularly as to those who aspire to earn MBA or law degrees. For many who earn these degrees, the return on investment is poor or non-existent. The burdens of...... - VoIP PBX - A Gateway For VoIP Call Termination The IP PBX serves as a gateway in order to transfer voice in Voice Over IP networks. This gateway actually plays the role of a telephone exchange as is found in traditional networks. The presence of PBX allows users of VoIP to send voice mails and messages to others living......
- Understanding Data Sources When you perform a mail merge, Word inserts an individual set of information (such as a recipient’s name and mailing address) into a copy of a document to customize or personalize the document. The sets of information come from a data source—a file that organizes information into fields and records......
- The Dynamics and Results of Intelligence and Security Defense will improve with the addition of epistemological and methodological advances and technological developments that occur within the field of knowledge management, and being laid in recent years the foundations for the formation and development of a new and autonomous scientific discipline of the same name. Continued progress in......
